|
Lahej 1915
Part 1 – Background and Events up to
3 July
One of the least well-known reverses
suffered by the British Army in the 1st World War was
what happened at Lahej in early July 1915. This article
tells the story of this defeat, a defeat not so much by
the enemy as by the elements.
The Turks might never have decided to
advance on Aden were it not for the British attack on
the fort at Sheikh Syed towards the end of November
1914. A division of the Indian Army was on its way to
Egypt from India and it was decided by the General Staff
in India that as long as the whole operation did not
take more than 24 hours one brigade should make an
assault landing against Fort Turba opposite
Perim.
Working to their own agenda the General Staff neither
asked for approval from London nor did it sound out the
authorities in Aden as to the wisdom of this enterprise.
The attack was a success but it had two adverse
repercussions: the Turks decided that attack was the
best means of defence and the local tribes were upset as
they had not been warned or consulted about the
operation.
In 1914 Fortress Aden seemed all but
impregnable to attack from the landward side. The
terrain North of Aden did not favour movement, and
certainly not by large bodies of troops. There were no
proper roads once outside the Settlement and few wells,
except in and around Lahej, until the mountains were
reached, some 40 miles or so away. The semi-circular arc
to the North of Aden was a virtual desert. An approach
from the West would have been especially difficult and
wisely was not attempted by the Turks. They could only
come from the North, following the two main caravan
routes from the Yemen, one from Kataba via
Dthala and
the other from Taiz via MusAmir, both routes meeting and
joining up at Nobat Dakim at the edge of the mountainous
area. The going from Nobat to Lahej was for the most
part quite reasonable; by and large the further South
one comes the more desert-like the conditions.
Had Aden had a much larger garrison,
a policy of forward defence based on a strong brigade at
Nobat Dakim (where there was a good water supply) would
have been best, but this option was not available as the
whole garrison was no more than a strong independent
brigade. The war plan was therefore to hold and defend
Lahej, which would deny the use of the wells there to an
enemy as well as keeping an enemy at arm’s length from
Sheikh Othman. The critical weakness of Fortress Aden
was that it depended to a very large extent on the water
that was piped in from the wells at Sheikh Othman. To be
able to defend forward there were contingency plans to
form a moveable column from troops in the garrison. The
Aden Moveable Column (AMC) had originally been set up to
undertake punitive expeditions into the hinterland, the
last such being the Ad Dareja Punitive Expedition in
1901 to destroy two forts put up by the Turks inside
what the British reckoned was their side of the border.
The AMC had been deployed again in 1902 to provide a
supporting force for the Aden Boundary Commission in its
joint demarcation of the border area, the Turks after
Al Dareja having agreed that one was necessary. This
deployment lasted over two years and apart from anything
else it resulted in a good set of logistic procedures
being established. The big weakness of the AMC was that
it could not be deployed at short notice as there were
no transport camels held on the establishment. In
1903/04 over 2,000 camels had been required to support
troops operating in the hinterland, of which the AMC
accounted for less than half.
A new Resident,
Major General Shaw,
had arrived in Aden at towards the end of November 1914.
Shaw was GOC as well as Resident and with the
possibility of an advance out to
Lahej at some stage, on
23 December he recommended to the office of the Chief of
the General Staff (CGS) in India (not to be confused
with the Chief of the Imperial General Staff in England)
that a telegraph line be laid from Steamer Point to
Lahej and the route to there improved. Approval for both
projects was given the next day, the telegraph link to
Lahej being opened on 1 March. Detachments of the 23rd
Sikh Pioneers, 327 all ranks all told, were employed on
route improvement from the end of December to
mid-February. The 23rd was an infantry
battalion with additional training as assault pioneers.
It had come from India for the landing against Fort
Turba, when it had used its expertise in demolitions to
good effect, and had then been sent back to Aden to
reinforce the garrison there. The major problem South
of Lahej was drifting sand and in spite of much use of
locally made fascines it was very difficult to keep any
of the three possible routes clear. On 9 January the 23rd
attempted to pass an unloaded 2.5 ton lorry along the
route via Bir Amr but it got stuck in sand a mile North
of that place.
On Christmas Eve the Sultan of Lahej,
normally referred to as ‘the Abdali’ had reported that
five regular Turkish battalions were at Kataba together
with five larger-sized guns. This news spurred Shaw to
do a reconnaissance of Lahej, taking with him the three
staff officers of Aden Brigade and his 1st
Assistant (referred to as the FAR), Lieutenant Colonel
Jacob. They travelled in
motor cars, of which there were
already quite a few in Aden, mostly Fords. Whilst the
three most senior officers were selecting a camping
ground, which they sited near the government well at Ath
Thalub, with space for a whole brigade, the two junior
officers carried out a reconnaissance of the eastern
track from Bir Salim towards Bir Amir. [Bir Amir was on
the eastern route via Fiyush and is not to be confused
with Bir Amr on the central route.] They reported that
it was very sandy about three miles South of Lahej and
heavy guns would need extra camels to pass this part of
the route.
In mid-February the Army Commander of
the Indian Southern Army visited Aden. Shaw took the
opportunity of asking for some mountain or pack camel
guns to give the AMC the mobility to venture beyond the
foothills if that was required. This request was to
eventually have a positive result as at the end of March
Aden was informed that a small battery of four 10-pdr
pack camel guns would be shipped from India on 4 April.
In Aden there were then discussions as to how these guns
were to be manned, as no extra men were being sent.
Range and fuse tables for the 10-pdrs arrived on the 30th,
by which time training was going well and special camels
were being taken on. Towards the end of May the CGS
would be asked to sanction the use of 200 rounds of
ammunition as the crews had not yet fired this
particular weapon.
Early in May the CGS wanted to know
the planned composition of the AMC; in total it was just
over 1,500 all ranks, plus a wing (half-battalion) of
the 126th Baluchis guarding the Line of
Communication (L of C). If the AMC went into the hills
the radius of action would be no further than Ad Dareja
or Dthala and an extra double company would be needed on
the L of C. In addition the six towed 15-pdrs in the
only field battery would have to be left at either Nobat
Dakim or Lahej.
The Baluchi half-battalion had
arrived as a reinforcement towards the end of March.
Although the 126th was an all-Hindu
battalion, one double company was Brahui and the other
non-Brahui – perhaps prone to the similar sort of
problems that an Iraqi Moslem battalion that was half
Sunni and half Shiite would have! Anyway on 26 May the
two officers commanding the double companies went
together to the GOC to report a serious case of
insubordination, veering on mutiny, in the Brahui double
company. They insisted that to avoid serious trouble the
two double companies needed to be to be separated. It
was thought best to exchange the non-Brahui with one of
those of the 23rd Sikh Pioneers (also classed
as Hindus) so that there would still be a similar number
of Hindus and Moslems on the Isthmus position and four
Sikh and one non-Brahui double company at Steamer Point.
Of interest here is that it was standard procedure for
all ammunition magazines in the Settlement to be guarded
by British troops. One does not know the reason for the
near mutiny but the situation was deemed sufficiently
serious for one double company of the 109th
Infantry to be ordered to parade in the vicinity of the
Isthmus whilst the redeployment took place.
On 10 May, the day after the CGS’s
query on the composition of the column, units were
ordered to overhaul their operational procedures for a
moveable column. One change that was to have
far-reaching effect was that shorter marches decided on
because of the present unusually hot weather, which had
commenced around 18 April. Colonel Jacob (the FAR) was
ordered to get an up to date state of wells en route to
Dthala.
The next day the CGS reminded Shaw
that except in grave emergency the AMC was not to be
used outside the Settlement (i.e. beyond Sheikh Othman)
without the sanction of the Government of India. At the
end of May, with the situation deteriorating, the GSO of
Aden brigade, Major Bradshaw, recorded in the war diary
that it would be necessary to ascertain from the CGS
whether or not an advance by Turkish forces on Lahej
constituted a ‘grave emergency’ as there would be little
time to act.
On 24 April 3,000 Turks had been
reported to be moving South from Hodeida, destination
Taiz, where they should arrive in a fortnight. It also
had become apparent that the Turks were trying to win
over tribes in order to join their attack on Lahej and
Aden. Most of the Arab tribes did not want to be under
Turkish rule and would not readily join them. In the
Yemen the Imam relied on Aden for many of his supplies
and was believed to have withdrawn active support for
the time being. However those offering support included
two strategically important tribes on the main routes in
from the Yemen – the Amiri around Dthala and the
Haushabi, especially those around Mauia on the route
from Taiz to MusAmir. As early as 1 February there was a
report that the Turks had entered Dthala supported by
Arabs loyal to their cause.
On 27 May OC Perim reported that
1,600 Turks had left Sheikh Syed for the Dthala area.
This report, together with the one of Turks already at
Kataba and the other of the group moving to Taiz from
Hodeida would produce, when it had concentrated, a force
sufficient to mount a serious attack on Aden. The
problem was that the intelligence assessment of this
information, in particular that put forward by Jacob,
was that the Turks would not actually mount an attack on
Fortress Aden.
On 11 June there was an unconfirmed
report that some Turks had reached Mauia and therefore
the Abdali informed Aden that he was sending troops to
Nobat to assess the situation. The next day the presence
of Turks at Mauia was confirmed. In consequence on the
13th Shaw considered it imperative to send the camel
troop of the Aden Troop to support the Abdali, who at
that stage had 1,000 men and three guns covering the
approach to Lahej from the North. He had to ask India
for approval and this was given straight away, but
subject to a promise that the troop did not enter the
hills [North or West of Nobat Dakim]. The Aden Troop was
in effect a squadron of mounted infantry, half equipped
with camels and half with horses. Its strength was about
90 all ranks and was commanded by a British officer,
with Indian officers commanding the two halves. The next
day the CGS was informed that the pony troop [the other
half of the Aden Troop] was being sent to act as a
reserve for the Abdali’s force. India would query the
need for this additional deployment – an example of how
‘modern’ communications [cable] were allowing higher
authority to meddle in the conduct of operations. The
OC, Captain Norbury, was also the Political ADC to the
Resident. This was to prove an unfortunate bit of
double-hatting as one of his duties was organising his
master’s Mess when the latter was in the field wearing
his other hat as GOC Aden Brigade.
Meanwhile reports were coming in from
elsewhere. A Turkish attempt to capture Perim had been
easily thwarted, but it had been necessary to put a
whole double company (of the 23rd Sikh
Pioneers) on the island to ensure its defence, the extra
troops coming from Aden. In addition on 11 June Kamaran
island had been captured without a fight by a force of
about 500 men from Aden, most of whom were required to
remain there to defend the island. As a result of these
two actions there were about 500 less men to defend
Aden. India eventually promised to send another wing of
infantry to make up the deficit. Fortunately another
request at around this time, for about 1,000 troops to
be sent from Aden to Somaliland, was vetoed by Aden.
On 15 June the GSO recorded that it
had definitely been established that Turkish forces were
about to debouch from the hills on Lahej. He added a
note that if this was taken literally the Turks must
reach Lahej first as the Aden Brigade could not do 15
miles in one march in the abnormally hot weather. One
might think that this appreciation would have led to the
immediate deployment of the AMC but the previous day he
had written that due to the heat troops should only
leave [the comparative comfort of their barracks] at the
last possible moment. This was to prove to be false
logic.
Also on the 15th the headquarters of
the Aden Troop moved out to Lahej. This brought the
Troop’s strength there up to that laid down in the
contingency plans for the deployment of a Moveable
Column into the hinterland North of Aden to cover the
approaches from Turkish-held Yemen. Also on 15 June the
camel troop was moved further North to Nobat Dakim. As
has been mentioned this was a position of strategic
importance about 40 miles North of Aden as it was where
two of the three approach routes to Aden likely to be
used by the Turks converged - that from Mauia via
MusAmir and that from Dthala at a point where the
caravan route left the mountainous area [see Map 1].
The topography of the area was such
that there was line of sight communication from Nobat to
the signalling station located on the top of Sham Shan.
Communication was by heliograph, although heat haze on
occasions made signalling impossible. The next day, the
16th, the detachment at Nobat established
communications with brigade headquarters in Aden, via
Sham Shan. Having proved the link, the camel element
rejoined Troop HQ at Lahej on the 17th.
Later that day Captain Norbury moved up to Nobat
with a small escort and early on the 18th he inspected
the position that would be held by local Abdali forces
covering the Tannan defile on the route between MusAmir
and Nobat. Norbury returned to Lahej the same afternoon.
On the 20th he took over the duties of Intelligence
Officer Lahej from the GSO3 of Aden Brigade, Captain
Paige. From then until the end of the month the Troop at
Lahej carried out routine field training, although on
the 29th a detachment was again deployed to Nobat Dakim,
which on arrival re-established a signalling post to
communicate directly with Aden.
23 June was a very hot day, and in
fact the start of an abnormally hot period, even for
Aden. The next day General Shaw received a cable from
the CGS in India complaining that intelligence from Aden
was falling off in quality. The cable stated that more
money could be spent. It was too late for that as the
problem was largely with the command set-up in Aden.
Shaw had his office in the Residency in Steamer Point.
He was in effect Governor and under normal circumstances
spent at least 95% of his working day on non-military
matters governing the colony and dealing with the 10
main tribes in the protectorate. As has been mentioned
the Resident was also GOC Aden Brigade, which was really
a misnomer for Aden Garrison, the small headquarters of
which was located in Crater over four miles from the
Residency. The day-to-day running of the garrison was
left to two staff officers, a DAA&QMG (a Captain) and a
GSO2 (a Major), the former responsible for human
resources and logistics and the latter for operations
and training. What happened in the protectorate, and in
particular as regards intelligence, was the
responsibility and province of the Residency. The man
with special responsibility for the hinterland tribes
was the FAR, Colonel Jacob, who was on at least his
third tour in Aden and was a reasonably fluent Arabic
speaker. Thus Aden Brigade had no control over
intelligence gathering in the hinterland.
A major part of the garrison was
fixed artillery batteries located in the forts covering
Aden from attack from the sea. On the outbreak of war
the infantry element of the garrison had consisted of
only one Indian infantry battalion at full strength
(about 850 all ranks) and an under-strength British
battalion. The garrison was reinforced on the outbreak
of war and at the end of June 1915 the infantry element
of the garrison comprised the equivalent of about three
infantry battalions. Unfortunately the regular British
battalion had been replaced by a battalion of the
Territorial Army. The 1st Battalion of the
Brecknockshires, a Territorial battalion of the South
Wales Borderers, had arrived on 21 December 1914 to
replace a regular battalion needed elsewhere (the
Lancashire Fusiliers, fatefully, were destined to land
at Gallipoli). As well as not being acclimatised the
battalion was not yet sufficiently trained. In peacetime
battalions had always come from India and not the United
Kingdom, which ensured they were acclimatised. For the
time being, if the AMC had to deploy the Brecknockshires
would remain in Aden, taking over all four defence
Sectors, instead of the two they had taken over on
arrival. Early in January one of the Indian battalions
had taken over their sectors as it was realised that the
Brecknockshires needed more time to train and an
opportunity to exercise as a battalion. A training
syllabus was prepared in conjunction with the GOC and
four British officers were loaned from other units as
instructors. This training opportunity lasted just over
a month but even in mid-May the battalion was assessed
as only capable of facing irregular troops and also not
yet ‘seasoned’, in modern parlance not yet acclimatised.
A British regular battalion would have had the key role
on the deployment of a moveable column, but the
Brecknockshires were selected to be the reserve.
On 28 May Jacob and Paige (who as the
GSO3 of the brigade was also brigade intelligence
officer) motored out to Lahej to get an intelligence
update from the Abdali, with Jacob acting as interpreter
for Paige. Whilst they were away the Resident sent a
situation report to the CGS that it was evident that
Haushabi did not intend to fight or resist the Turks.
This was disturbing news as the tribal area of the
Haushabi stretched from inside the Yemen around Mauia
eastwards, across the northern boundary of the Abdali to
the Fadhli near the coast, to the east of Aden [see Map
1]. The Mauia route was that likely to be the main
Turkish axis of advance and the implication of this
assessment was that Turkish forces coming this way would
meet with no resistance until they arrived just North of
Lahej. With this in mind the GOC also stated that if the
news was confirmed he intended to deploy the Moveable
Column to Sheikh Othman on 1 July and he therefore
requested sanction to advance to Fiyush on 2 July.
Fiyush was important as it had one of the few wells
between Sheikh Othman and Lahej. He also asked the CGS
to expedite the move of the reinforcements that had been
agreed, the other wing (half-battalion) of the 108th
Infantry, one wing and battalion HQ being already in
Aden.
When Jacob and Paige returned from
Lahej the former reported that the Abdali had been
exaggerating and the situation was not so critical as
the Abdali had made out. In Jacob’s opinion there was no
need for the AMC to move out yet, but that camels had
better be collected. Paige reported that Ad Dareja (just
on the Aden side of the border on the route from Mauia)
was occupied by Turkish troops but that the enemy had
not yet crossed the border in strength. Jacob’s
assessment would soon prove to be faulty. The three or
four day delay in deploying was going to be the main
cause of the impending disaster.
At midday on the 30th orders were
received at Aden Brigade from the Residency for the AMC
to be prepared to march out on the following day. Soon
afterwards sanction was received from the CGS for the
GOC to operate in the defence of Lahej provided the AMC
did not become entangled in the foothills further North.
Deployment then would have not been too late but in
reply the GOC reported that as a result of the
investigations made at Lahej on the 29th he
had cancelled the move to Sheikh Othman but had asked
the Abdali to collect camel transport. Also on the 30th
the GOC recalled the OC of the Aden Troop so that he
could resume his duties as Political ADC, and
specifically to make arrangements to move the GOC’s
mess out to Lahej in the near future. Norbury’s recall
meant that there was now no British officer well forward
with the only unit with a reconnaissance role. In fact
no British officer would command this vital information
gathering unit until one was appointed by General Shaw’s
replacement on 19 July, two days before the advance to
retake Sheikh Othman. Also on 30 June news came from
India that the wing of the 108th Infantry had
left Bombay that day. Meanwhile a standing camp was
pitched at Sheikh Othman and camels in large numbers had
already been collected.
The problem on 1 July, yet another
very hot day, was a lack of hard intelligence as to
Turkish intentions. There were no reports of a Turkish
advance across the border. On 2 July OC Perim reported
that his agents at Sheikh Syed had told him that the
attack on Lahej would be made in three columns via
Hujeria, Mauia and Dthala. Events would show that this
was accurate information. That evening Jacob was
informed by the Sultan of Lahej that the main body of
Turks from Mauia had arrived at Al Dareja and that their
advance guard at was at Mileh. In addition another
column from Hujeria had reached Habil Masweda via Wadi
Akkan. Hujeria was North of Sheikh Syed and Habil
Masweda was between MusAmir and Nobat Dakim. This was
the column that had left Sheikh Syed towards the end of
May. This news prompted Shaw to send a telegram later
the same evening to the CGS saying that unless he
received orders to the contrary he intended to deploy
the Aden Movable Column (AMC) to Sheikh Othman the
following afternoon (3 July). A warning order for the
move was also issued to Aden Brigade.

Part 2 - The Advance to Lahej and the Retreat back to
Aden
[Note: The use of the word ‘retreat’ rather than
‘withdrawal’ is intentional, as will become apparent]
Part 1 ended with the issue of a Warning Order for the
Aden Moveable Column to deploy to Lahej. The Column was
to consist of about 1,000 infantry, drawn from four
separate battalions, two artillery batteries, one of six
15-pdrs drawn by camels and the other a pack battery of
four 10-pdrs carried on camels. There were also four
machine gun sections, one a brigade section and the
others from three of the four battalions, and a very
weak engineer company. This is an appropriate moment to
mention that battalions of Indian troops consisted of
four double rifle companies, each double company having
180 - 200 men. At that stage of the war a battalion
seldom had more than about nine or ten British officers;
thus not all individual companies (i.e. half a double
company) were commanded by British officers. Two double
companies of the 109th were to form the Advance Guard
and the order of march of the Main Body was to be:
-
Battalion HQ and one double company 126th Baluchis
-
Fortress Company Sappers & Miners (-)
-
10-pdr battery
-
detachment 23rd Sikh Pioneers (providing signallers and Column HQ)
-
15-pdr battery
-
Battalion HQ and four companies 1st Brecknockshires
-
field hospital
-
ammunition column
-
1st line transport
-
reserve of water
One can see that right from the start the British
battalion was being given a lesser role than that
normally given to battalions within a brigade of the
Indian Army. One would have expected the battalion to
have formed the advance guard or at least the leading
element of the main body. But it was acknowledged that
the Brecknocks were still neither fit enough nor
sufficiently trained to justify being given a leading
role.
At six that evening the GOC went out to Sheikh Othman to see commanding
officers of the infantry units and to inform them that
the march must be continued at 0300 hrs the following
morning. They nearly all protested, explaining how done
their men were after the heat of the march to Sheikh
Othman. But General Shaw had not been there to see how
trying the conditions had been and he explained that an
‘effort’ must be made. (Like the word ‘demonstration’
the word ‘effort’ had a particular meaning in the
context of orders. In effect it was an order to press on
as quickly as possible.) He then placed Lt Col Pearson
in command of the Main Body and directed it to march at
0300 hrs. Pearson was the CO of the 23rd Sikh Pioneers,
two companies of which were defending Perim. The 23rd
was an infantry battalion with additional training as
assault pioneers. Only 85 others from Pearson’s
battalion went out with the moveable column on its
initial deployment. These included his two machine gun
sections as column troops and a weak platoon providing
the escort to the 15-pdr battery. But his unit also
provided 15 signallers, two for his own detachments but
more interestingly 13 described as ‘brigade signallers’.
The War Diary of the 23rd has him leaving Aden as
‘Temporary Commandant Mobile Column’, with his Adjutant,
Captain Squires, designated as ‘Staff Officer’. In
effect the 23rd from the outset provided column
headquarters. On deployment of the column the two
professional staff officers of Aden Brigade, the GSO2
and the DAA&QMG, remained at their desks in Aden. This
was what had occurred in 1901 and 1903 when sizeable
columns had been deployed away from Fortress Aden, under
command of the senior Lieutenant Colonel of the units
involved. It is easy to say now that General Shaw should
have commanded the column from the outset; however his
duties as Resident, and the fact that over half his
troops were still in Aden, plus the need for him to be
contactable by the CGS in India determined that he
should only come out to take command in the field once
deployment to Lahej was complete. (It is worth noting
here that Shaw’s successor, Major General Younghusband,
did not actually command the brigade which re-took
Sheikh Othman later in July)
Before returning to Aden Shaw took one further decision,
one that would have important implications for the
morrow. He decided that the column would advance from
Sheikh Othman to Lahej along the Bir Amr route and not
by the Fiyush route which was the one that had been
prepared for use and had the best surface. An engineer
officer had just been along the Fiyush route and had
assessed it to be in fair condition. No reason for the
change is given in the War Diary, although the greater
number of wells on the Bir Amr route was probably the
deciding factor.
Shaw then returned to Aden from where he sent a cable to
the CGS. This made no mention of the problems
encountered on the march to Sheikh Othman due to the
heat. Only that a small detachment of the 109th
Infantry with some Maxims were ‘being pushed up in
motors’ at midnight 3/4 July to support the Aden troop
which was already at Lahej. He also mentioned that the
Movable Column would resume its march at 0300 hrs on the
4th.
Colonel Jacob then tried to persuade Shaw not to go out to Lahej until
6 July because his assessment was that the Turks would
never come. The GSO made an entry in the War Diary that
he himself succeeded in convincing the GOC that they
would. Shaw than made the decision not to leave Aden to
join up with the Column till 1500 hrs the following day,
4 July. Jacob obtained permission to postpone his own
departure until the 6th. In truth he should
have already have been in Lahej with the advance guard.
On the morning of the 4th the GSO realised
that a departure at 1500 hrs was too late and he
persuaded the GOC to leave an hour or so earlier. On the
way out the two cars carrying the GOC’s party stopped at
the Keith Falconer hospital at Sheikh Othman, where many
of the heat exhaustion cases were being treated. The GSO
was aware that commanders at Lahej must be waiting to
receive new orders from Shaw and at 1530 hrs he had to
urge the GOC to press on without delay. From now on
things were to go from bad to worse for the command
group in its attempt to get forward. The diary entry for
1700 hrs says it all:
“motors going very badly constantly stopping in sand.
Several parties of Brecknocks overcome with heat, some
dead, encountered en route. GOC stopped to speak to each
[party]. Going bad had to walk long distances. Numbers
of exhausted Brecknocks increasing. At Bir Amr GOC gave
over cars to sick men and commenced riding.”
The situation at the next diary entry, timed at 1830
hrs, was no better:
“Saw columns of smoke arising in the direction of Lahej.
Pushed on. As it became dark saw shells bursting over
Lahej. Came on 15-pdr guns stuck in sand and unable to
move. Met men of all regiments moving to the rear.
Stopped them on gun position. Transport mules and more
men all [sic] saying they had been ordered to retire.
Extraordinary tales told of what had happened to troops
in Lahej. GOC’s Abdali escort now bolted - and only
means of communicating quickly with OC Main Body.”
With only a very sketchy picture of what was happening
in Lahej Shaw could only send a very short situation
report to India that evening. He cabled that part of the
AMC, supported by the battery of 10-pdrs, had taken up a
position just North of Lahej from where it could support
the Sultan’s force. What Shaw did not report, and
perhaps did not know as he was not with the AMC at this
stage, was that this advance guard was exhausted and in
no fit state to fight even a defensive battle. On seeing
this report on the morning of 5 July the Director of
Military Operations in India (DMO) added a far-sighted
comment:
“The Aden Column is operating under severe climatic
conditions, and is not at all too strong. Have a plan
ready to reinforce Aden garrison if necessary."
It was to be nearly 60 hours before the next situation
report from Shaw would reach India, which must have
worried the CGS somewhat.
The command group rode on with increasing urgency to
find out what was happening and to get in touch with
troops in Lahej. At about 1915 hrs some men of the 126th
Infantry seized the GOC’s bridle to prevent him riding
forward as they thought enemy were on the road between
him and Lahej. Deciding that discretion was the better
part of valour, at 2000 hrs the GOC decided to return to
the 15-pdr gun position which was on sand dunes about
three and a half miles from Lahej. He then sent forward
a Sub Assistant Surgeon to reconnoitre the road ahead
and with a message for OC Main Body. That worthy soon
returned saying enemy were on the road near Lahej. By
2200 hrs a considerable number of men from the
Brecknocks and the 126th Baluchis had been stopped on
the gun position on their way rearwards, all calling for
water. Officers and men alike were exhausted. There were
also unconfirmed reports that hostile local tribesmen
were working round on a flank. Soon after Lieut Bingham,
109th, Orderly Officer to the GOC, returned from Lahej.
He confirmed that troops were withdrawing and that
casualties among officers and men had been very heavy.
[In fact battle casualties had been extremely light:
nearly all casualties were from heat exhaustion.]
The GSO then put a formal appreciation of the situation to the GOC that
want of water was the ruling factor and that the wells
two miles further back must be secured for the troops to
retire on, or to advance from the next day. The OC of
the 15-pdr camel battery stated that he could move his
guns back by sections two miles if he had two to three
hours to rest his men. The GOC approved this plan and
guns and men began withdrawing to the well known as Bir
Nasir. The command party reached the well at 0100 hrs on
5 July. On arrival the GSO marked out a perimeter camp
with the best fields of fire astride the road, which was
among acacia trees. He put men in defensive positions
covering the road, with scouts out. He also organised
the distribution of a small water ration to each man as
well as sending a message by an Abdali horseman to OC
Main Body to ask for a situation report. So what had
been happening around Lahej?
The weak battalion group, based on the 109th Inf, had at
last light taken up a defensive position covering the
main route from the North into Lahej. Part of the Aden
Troop was deployed forward astride the ‘road’ as a
screen. The main position on the road consisted of a
double company of the 109th and the battalion's two
machine gun sections, still with their escort. Out
covering the left flank was Capt Barr with three
quarters of his double company. The right flank was
being covered by the 23rd Sappers & Miners with a
machine gun section from the 23rd Pioneers. In ‘local
reserve’, in the centre, was the remainder of Barr’s
double company, under Lieut Kane together with the Aden
Troop, less the detachment deployed as a screen. Soon
after last light Lieut Kane took his half company to
support Capt Barr on the left flank as the latter
appeared to be rather isolated. [There is no record of
his having been ordered to move.]
At 2030 hrs Capt Barr received a report that the troops in the centre
had fallen back to the area of the Guest House. Since he
was also worried that the enemy were getting round on
the left of his position, he decided [without orders] to
withdraw his two companies through the town to the Guest
House. On arriving there, however, he found that the
position in the centre had not withdrawn. He tried to
get back to his original position but was unable to do
so.
At 2300 hrs the remaining subunits were ordered to withdraw to the area
of the Guest House. Whilst withdrawing down the main
street of Lahej one group managed to capture a section
of Turkish machine guns. About 100 men appear to have
retreated further back to the encampment to the South of
the Guest House. At midnight a fighting patrol was sent
out back into the town to clear some Turks out of some
houses. Since this patrol was commanded by Captain
Squires, the Staff Officer to the OC Main Body, Lt Col
Pearson, one can perhaps assume that the latter officer
was in command at the Guest House. The patrol returned
soon after, with Squires mortally wounded. He was the
only British officer to be killed in action.
Capt Stocker with his Sappers & Miners reached the encampment at 0030
hrs. He gathered together all the stragglers who had
fetched up there, including about 100 men of the 109th,
and led them all back to the area of the Guest House,
without encountering any enemy.
Returning to the GOC’s predicament of being totally out of touch, at
0300 hrs Capt Norbury (Shaw’s ADC) arrived from Lahej.
The GSO wrote in the Diary that Norbury had reported
that is was impossible to hold Lahej and that our troops
were surrounded, as well as being heavily shelled and
outranged by the enemy’s guns. On hearing this report
the GOC sent a junior NCO of the Aden Troop with a
message for Lt Col Pearson that he was permitted to
withdraw to Bir Nasir if his position was untenable. The
Sowar later returned saying he had been unable to
deliver the message. Fortunately Pearson was acting on
his own initiative and at 0445 hrs had organised to
evacuate all casualties from the Guest House garden, and
to withdraw his force to Sheikh Othman. All wounded, and
those still suffering from the effects of heatstroke who
were unable to march, were sent back on all available
camels, which included those of a section of 10-pdr
mountain guns which had to be abandoned as a result.
A rearguard, consisting of Barr’s double company, was the last to leave
the Guest House at 0600 hrs, arriving at Bir Amir two
hours later, where they rested. The Main Body, centred
on the other double company of the 109th,
arrived at Bir Mahomed at 1000 hrs, where they rested up
for the remainder of daylight hours. They moved on again
at 1900 hrs when the rearguard arrived. The Main Body
arrived at Sheikh Othman at 0300 hrs on 6 July. The
above timings have all been taken from the War Diary of
the 109th.
From the GSO’s diary one notes that troops from Lahej had begun to
arrive at Bir Nasir from 0600 hrs on the 5th. The upside
was that the 109th brought in eight Turkish
prisoners, including a major and a captain, which helped
to balance the news that two guns had been lost. The
well at Bir Nasr ran dry at 0830 hrs. The GSO noted that
the GOC then decided to withdraw to the next well one
mile further back as lack of transport, food and water
and ammunition had completely ruled out any possibility
of an advance, without even considering the state of the
troops, who were absolutely exhausted. He noted further
that the Brecknocks had been unable to cope and were
‘entirely exhausted’. As they comprised the infantry
reserve, in numbers half the column, an advance was out
of the question.
Therefore at 0900 hrs the GOC ordered a withdrawal to the next well one
mile to the rear. This was the well at Bir Amir but as
the troops were on the move they were taken on to a well
another mile and a half further South. The Brecknocks
did not arrive there till nightfall as they had taken
shelter in the grass huts at Bir Amir en route. This was
the reason for the rearguard not reaching Bir Mahomed
until last light.
Some of the measures that had been taken in Aden were as follows: the
Senior Naval Officer was asked [sic] to move the Empress
of Asia onto the eastern shore as enemy had been
reported near Sheikh Othman; meanwhile the Northbrook
and the Minto were standing by in the inner harbour
covering the western shore; three maxim guns from the
Fort’s MG Section were moved to the Isthmus position and
a maxim section from the Northbrook was landed and sent
up to Sheikh Othman; the OC Aden (in the absence of the
GOC), Lt Col Warren commanding the RGA, put a request to
the French Consul to telegraph for permission to land a
draft of French troops aboard the transport Elkantara
that was due in Aden that evening. This was as a
precaution as the half-battalion of 108th Inf
had not yet arrived from Bombay. On 6 July Warren had
troops manning an outpost line at Sheikh Othman, through
which the Column could withdraw. He had also deployed
one double company from No.2 Sector defences forward on
the Khormaksar line. Transport and resupply had been a
major problem as all available transport had been sent
forward to assist in the withdrawal of the Column.
Motorised transport was at a premium and the owners of
private motorcars did sterling work in helping to bring
in the heat exhaustion cases. This was the situation
when Shaw arrived back in Aden on the morning of 6 July.
Part 3
– Shaw Replaced and the Re-taking of Sheikh Othman
On his return to Aden Shaw sent a long situation report to the CGS in
India. Although it was sent (or more to the point sent
for enciphering) at 1200hrs on the 6th it was
not with the CGS until 1500 hrs the following day. It
was far too long-winded for an initial report and the
summary sent from India to the Secretary of State for
India (S of S) by cable with a ‘clear the line’
precedence was suitably succinct. Shaw’s report was as
follows:
“At 4 p.m. on July 4th the Aden troop, which until then
remained in observation, reported the presence of a
Turkish force estimated at
500
Turks including cavalry, with four field guns, machine guns
and a large contingent of Arabs. As this force was
advancing, the Aden troop fell back at the same hour (4
p.m.) on the Lahej position. The position faced North
and was held by all the troops who had been able to
reach Lahej, namely 250 British and Indian infantry,
with a battery of 10-pdr guns. These troops maintained
their position until 10 p.m. under the fire of the
enemy’s artillery. By this time the northern edge of
Lahej, on which the Turkish fire had been partially
directed, was observed to be on fire and at the same
time a change of front was necessitated by a hostile
flanking movement from the mound.
During the night, hostile attacks from the West were
beaten off, some hand to hand fighting taking place. But
some parties of the enemy, who had penetrated Lahej from
the North, continued practically throughout the night to
attack with shell and rifle fire our troops and the
hospital which was situated in a garden to the South of
the town. The remaining British and Indian troops who,
owing to want of water, had been unable to reach Lahej,
were collected to cover the 15-pdr battery which in
consequence of the deep sand and lack of extra camel
transport had found it impossible to advance by 7 p.m.
beyond a point about four and a half miles South of
Lahej. At 12 midnight this supporting force was
withdrawn to cover the water supply at Bir Nasr two
miles further South.
Having been informed that, owing to the desertion of all
transport and camelmen, and the treachery of our Arab
friendlies, the troops in Lahej were no longer able to
maintain their position in face of and under shell fire
of the superior forces of Turks and Arabs, I ordered
this force to use all available transport for the
removal of sick and wounded, and to withdraw to the
water at Bir Nasr. The withdrawal was carried out at
0500 on the 5th but owing to the necessity of using the
only available means of transport for carrying the
wounded and sick, three-quarters of the ammunition, all
kits and equipment together with two 10-pdr guns and
some .450 machine guns were abandoned at Lahej. I left
Bir Nasr at 0930 a.m. and, in view of the fact that our
troops were suffering very severely from great shortness
of water and food, withdrew the force to the next water
supply at Bir Amr. The enemy did not follow up and the
retirement was continued at 4 p.m., Sheikh Othman being
reached at 9 a.m. on 6 July.”
On the evening of the 6th the troopship Teesta carrying
drafts for Egypt from India called at Aden and was
detained. A cable was sent to India requesting that
these men could be used to reinforce the garrison.
Whilst a reply was awaited the OC Troops, Capt Faris,
was ordered to be ready to disembark the 500 men aboard,
which included one double company of the 7th
Gurkhas. Altogether there were two British and 20 Indian
officers. No personal weapons were aboard the ship.
Shaw sent his next report in a telegram dated 1230 hrs on 7 July. His
previous telegrams had all been sent wearing his GOC’ s
hat, so to speak. This one was ominously from ‘The
Resident’.
“It is reported that Turkish strength at Lahej is eight
battalions and 20 guns and that their intention is to
attack Aden on July 9th. The Turks have offered an
amnesty to all Abdali who return, and have proclaimed a
Hausabi Sultan of Lahej.
In my opinion, owing in reduction in numbers of my force
through excessive heat, and to loss of ammunition and
transport through desertion of transport, it is
impossible at this season to defend the long line
necessary to protect Sheikh Othman from all sides,
without thereby unduly exposing Aden, which is of
Imperial importance.
For these reasons I have withdrawn into the Aden
defences, and placed an outpost line extending from
cavalry lines to Khormaksar bridge, supported by HM
ships Minto, Northbrook, Empress of Russia and Empress
of Asia, in order to protect Admiralty wireless station,
which I believe is thought second to defence of Aden.
As four companies of 108th do not arrive
before 8 July I have disembarked 500 men from Teesta and
armed them with Martini Henry and .303 rifles.”
Shaw had not waited for permission to use the men from the Teesta; they
had been disembarked after dark on the 6th ,
but the Secretary of State’s telegram saying they could
be retained only arrived on the 8th. The .303
rifles were surplus rifles of the 109th
Infantry and the obsolete Martini Henrys were from the
stockpile held to be given to loyal tribal chiefs, as
and when they needed to be rewarded/bribed.
Shaw was also looking around for any other reinforcements that might be
able to be got to Aden in a hurry, should the situation
worsen. He asked the Commissioner in British Somaliland
if he could lend two naval guns and any mounted or
dismounted troops. The latter replied that he could send
the two guns, each with 100 rounds of ammunition, and
350-400 troops of whom 150 could be sent immediately.
The Secretary of State’s telegram referred to above had
also mentioned that half a battalion of Australian
troops and an Indian battalion could be spared from
Egypt.
The reinforcement situation improved when the wing of the 108th
eventually arrived on the morning of the 8th.
With the Teesta ‘battalion’ now disembarked and armed,
the Somaliland reinforcements were stood down for the
time being. As soon as they had disembarked the 108th,
together with the double company of Gurkhas from the
Teesta, took over the outpost line at Khormaksar, with
the remainder of the Teesta Battalion in reserve at the
Admiralty Wireless Station. Shaw’s second report was
much shorter than his initial one but given the time
taken to encode, transmit and decode it, it was still
not received by the Army Staff in Calcutta until 1125
hrs the following day, 8 July. Not surprisingly the CGS
wanted more information and that afternoon Shaw was told
to telegraph him with full details of casualties, losses
of ammunition and equipment and the state of the troops,
in particular the Brecknocks. He was also to give the
strength of the mobile column when it left Aden and how
many guns and machine guns were deployed. Next the CGS
wanted Shaw’s views on the present situation and his
intentions. The final request was about the availability
of water. For what sized force was water obtainable at
Sheikh Othman, at Lahej, on the road to Lahej, and then
on to Nobat Dakim.
The CGS had quickly decided what was required: Aden must be reinforced
and the situation restored, and Shaw replaced. Within
hours of receiving Shaw’s report he had the Viceroy’s
office telegraph the Secretary of State in London to
approve of the intention to reoccupy Lahej. It was
estimated that to achieve this a force consisting of at
least one infantry brigade, one cavalry regiment and two
artillery batteries would be required, over and above
any reinforcements already on their way or in the
garrison at Aden. All this force could not be found from
India but if the infantry brigade could be found from
Egypt, India could provide the remainder. Given the
choice India would select Younghusband’s brigade. In any
event the services of Younghusband himself were required
to relieve General Shaw as GOC and Resident at Aden as
the CGS had lost confidence in Shaw’s ability to be in
charge of Aden.
A further short telegram sent by Shaw on the evening of 7 July cannot
have eased the worries of those in India. Shaw reported
that he was having to impose non-statutory martial law
in Aden on account of the grave situation that had
arisen. In addition a telegram the same day to the
Director of Medical Services in India gave a further
hint of the disaster that had befallen. He asked for two
sections of an Indian Field Ambulance to be sent at once
to replace two that had been lost. He also asked for one
section of a British Field Ambulance and for 1,000 field
dressings. The DMS replied on 8 July that the equipment
for the three field ambulances would be sent as soon as
shipping was available. He asked for Shaw to telegraph
if it was absolutely essential to send personnel and to
send further details.
The Ordnance Branch in India reacted to Shaw’s initial report of
ammunition losses by making arrangements to send one
thousand rounds of 15-pdr shrapnel and one million
rounds of .303 ball ammunition, with a request to the
General Staff that if possible it should be shipped from
India on 11 July.
The Secretary of State for India, having consulted the War Office and
Kitchener, gave his decision on 9 July, or in other
words within hours of receiving the Viceroy’s request.
As a temporary measure Younghusband’s brigade and two
batteries of artillery were to be sent from Egypt to
Aden. Younghusband was to leave for Aden at the first
opportunity. Due to the water water situation Kitchener
had queried the advisability of sending a complete
cavalry regiment from India.
The Secretary of State in the same telegram asked who was the next
senior [Political] officer Aden. He assumed Jacob was
still there. Jacob, as 1st Assistant to the
Resident, would have been the next senior Political
Officer. He had not served with troops for at least 10
years, from the time of his transfer to the Political
Service.
On 10 July a telegram was sent to Shaw telling him he was being
relieved. The same telegram mentioned that a ship had
left Karachi on 5 July with two 5-inch guns for Perim.
These should arrive at Aden on 11 July and that Shaw
could keep them at Aden if he wished.
Regarding the queries about water supply, Aden replied that between the
two routes from Sheikh Othman to Lahej there was
drinking water for only two British battalions. In or
around Lahej there was pure water for a division, and
that at Nobat Dakim the river there could also meet the
requirements of a division. Shaw was then asked more
questions about water: what resources for carrying water
did he now possess, and what additional equipment would
be needed to support four various artillery batteries,
two squadrons of cavalry, an engineer company and a
brigade of four Indian infantry battalions?
But water supply problems of a more urgent nature and
closer to home were now a worry for both Aden garrison
and the civilian population. Water was available from
four sources but much the best quality water was that
that came via an aqueduct from wells at Sheikh Othman.
The entry in the Engineer War Diary for 8 July is
pertinent: “Anticipating that the duct water supply
from Sheikh Othman will be cut, I stopped the issue of
duct water to private individuals on payment, took over
certain Government wells which were leased out to
contractors, and arranged for the issue of [condensedJ
water on payment. Suggested to GOC that all water
supplies should be taken over and a committee appointed
to draw up rules and control the issue and distribution
of water to the inhabitants.” The Turks cut off the
duct water supply the following day.
On 10 July Younghusband left Suez for Aden aboard the
light cruiser HMS Philomel. The same day the 1/4th
Hampshire Howitzer Battery and the 24th
Hazara Mountain Battery, plus the 5th Company of 1st
Battalion Sappers and Miners were mobilised in India for
service under Younghusband in Aden. On the afternoon of
the 10th a troopship carrying the 12th
Australian Light Horse arrived in harbour. Also on 10
July one of the Turkish prisoners captured at Lahej
volunteered useful information as to the strength and
composition of the Turkish forces involved in the attack
on 4/5 July. The infantry consisted of only five weak
battalions of about 350 men in each, plus one squadron
of mounted infantry, supported by 10 mountain guns. In
addition about 400 Arabs were with the Turks. Here it is
a good moment to mention the problems facing the
attackers. The Turks were on exterior lines of
communication and if the comparatively recent civil war
in the Yemen was anything to go by their logistics and
resupply chain would have left a lot to be desired (see
Revolt in Yemen). The complete lack of proper
roads within the Aden Protectorate meant that it would
have been virtually impossible to resupply the size of
force that would have been needed to capture fortress
Aden. One other factor is worth mentioning. On 14 July
information would be received that the enemy did not
intend to advance on Aden during Ramadan.
On 12 July the C-in-C in India sent written orders by
telegram for Younghusband, care of Shaw. Shaw was to
have them deciphered in time to hand them to
Younghusband on the latter’s arrival, which was
estimated to be the evening of 13 July. The C-in-C also
informed Shaw that he had decided that the latter would
remain in Aden for the time being, at Younghusband’s
disposal.
The next day the GOC 5th Division was
informed by the Adjutant General in India that the 1st/4th
Royal West Kents were to be prepared to move at short
notice to relieve the Brecknockshires. Also on 13 July
Shaw telegraphed India that the aeroplanes referred to
in his telegram of 7 December 1914 would be of
incalculable value. Was there any chance of getting
them? Evidently the answer was negative, as no
aeroplanes were to be sent to Aden until late 1917,
although the seaplane carrier HMS Ben-Ma-Cree would
operate in Aden waters for a short period
mid-1916.
There had been one particularly unfortunate case of
‘blue-on-blue’ during the brief defence of Lahej. The
Abdali himself, the Sultan of Lahej, had been shot and
mortally wounded when he rounded a street corner on
horseback. He died in Aden on 13 July following an
operation necessitated by his wound. The GSO made
another cryptic remark in his Diary: “Political
Officer [Jacob] should have accompanied Column.”
Younghusband took over from Shaw at midday on 15 July.
The same day it was decided in India that Brigadier
General Price would be sent to Aden to take over the
duties of Resident. By the 15th
Younghusband’s brigade was well on its way from Egypt,
the last elements having left on the 13th. It
consisted of over 3,500 men, including 74 British and 80
Indian officers, plus 567 mules and 532 horses. The
artillery consisted of eight 15-pdr guns. The infantry
battalions were the 51st and 53rd
Sikhs and the 52nd and 56th
Punjabis. Ammunition accompanying the brigade included
600 rounds per gun, 30,000 rounds per Maxim and 1,000
rounds per rifle.
A Reuters news release seen in Aden mentioned that the
monitors HMS Severn and HMS Mersey were in East African
waters. Aden telegraphed India that these two ships
would be most useful at Aden.
Younghusband’s first situation report must have been
well received in India.
“There is no cause for any alarm or despondency in
situation here. Practically impossible for any hostile
forces which could be brought against Aden to take it. I
consider arrangements (by Shaw) quite secure and
suitable but as soon as troops arrive from Egypt I shall
occupy Sheikh Othman on three miles from present
outposts, as a detached post, strongly entrenching
around water supply. I do not recommend any further
military operations in this season. Two strong brigades,
fully equipped, are required to advance on Lahej. Only
Brecknocks not satisfactory.”
At 1325 hours on 21 July Younghusband was able to send
the following telegram to India: “This morning Sheikh
Othman was reoccupied. Small casualties. Report follows.”
He subsequently reported that the situation was well
under control and quite secure. Casualties were two
British officers killed, both from 53rd
Sikhs, and one wounded, plus 20 Indian soldiers killed
or wounded. Turkish forces at Sheikh Othman were
estimated as having been 600 men, supported by two field
guns and two machine guns.
Aden
never did get the additional troops that would be needed
to retake Lahej, nor did the Turks make any effort to
bring up the men and equipment that would be necessary
to capture Fortress Aden. For both sides the priorities
were elsewhere, and more than three years of stalemate
ensued.
Inglebyj |